EU ETS extension: opportunities and challenges of a quantity control

The European Commission’s Fit for 55 package enhances the importance of carbon pricing, envisioning an extension of the EU Emission Trading System (ETS). Among its main highlights, we see an extension to the transport and building sectors, an end to free ETS allocations, a revision of the energy taxation with greater emphasis on environmental aspects and the elimination of harmful subsidies.
There are important overlaps with Germany’s system, which has been extended earlier this year and acted like a sort of blueprint for the EU. However, there are also significant differences in the approach used to set control mechanisms: Germany opted for a price control while the EU went for a quantity control. Germany has set fixed prices rising steadily from €25 to 55 per CO2 ton through 2025, and a corridor in 2026 (€55-65/CO2ton).
The EU caps CO2 quantity through a “backstop” mechanism: a 5,15% linear reduction factor (the LRF defines the annual decrease of allowances provided to the market either via free allocation or via auctions) is set in line with the Effort Sharing Regulation targets (the ESR sets national targets for emission reductions, ensuring that Member States with higher GDP per capita have higher reduction targets), and later on adjusted according to the related emission reductions.
Both mechanisms generate challenges and opportunities. With a price control politics might defy science, meaning that the agreed prices might not allow for the necessary emissions reduction; on the other hand, certainty is ensured in planning ahead. If a quantity control can grant higher extents of emissions reduction, it risks generating instability due to potential price surprises. To estimate revenues in a free-floating price environment might be difficult for the programs that complement the ETS; however, expectations of increasing prices can make a difference in purchase choices.
Support for carbon pricing among German citizens has risen over the past years as government and civil society prioritized balancing the social impacts and facilitated by high analytical capacity and surveys. Revenues from carbon pricing are set to flow into ring fenced Climate and Energy Fund, used to lower electricity rates, while additional tax-financed compensation measures have been specifically designed for low-income/high burden households.
The use of revenues envisioned by the EU goes along the same spirit, but further efforts are needed to increase public support. Revenues are used for climate and energy-related purposes, with at least 50% dedicated to low-income households and another 25% set to flow into the Climate Action Social Facility. Building non-state carbon pricing “constituencies” may be essential in member states with low regulatory quality.
Carbon pricing needs high society engagement and clarity on revenue distribution schemes is a key strategic variable. Carbon pricing literacy through education is also fundamental to build greater public support.

From his keynote speech at WCP Webinar: Assessing the EU proposal to extend the ETS in light of the experiences with Germany’s new system, 16 July 2021 – Video accessible here

Carbon price news worldwide
- Election 2022:Albanese's small-target Labor now needs a big agenda - AFR Maggio 22, 2022His biggest problem is that his core promise to reverse the cost of ... the existing “safeguard mechanism” that acts as a de facto carbon price, ...
- Greenko to supply green power to ArcelorMittal, Ayana Renewable, 3 states from Kurnool plant Maggio 22, 2022The plant which is being set up at a cost of USD 3 billion is the ... 15 million tonnes (MT) of carbon dioxide, which is equal to the emissions ...
- Election 2022 results: Anthony Albanese must balance expectations with reality Maggio 22, 2022... of endorsing a mechanism with an implicit price on carbon by modifying ... a decade ago when it did a deal with the Greens on a carbon price.
- The Gemini Countryside factory where houses are built | Chester and District Standard Maggio 22, 2022... away factory in Cheshire – and at a fraction of the carbon cost. ... Each open panel timber frame house emits 14,460kg less carbon dioxide ...
- Ripple Pledges $100 Million to Help Save Earth From Climate Change | Cryptoglobe Maggio 22, 2022San Francisco-based FinTech firm Ripple has announced a $100M commitment to "scale and strengthen" global carbon markets.